Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Call Now
Available 24 Hours a Day
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • instagram
Naples Personal Injury Attorney > Blog > News > Did you know these things are withheld from a Jury in a PI trial?

Did you know these things are withheld from a Jury in a PI trial?

In case you are ever involved in an accident that results in a trial for damages or in case you are called to participate in a jury panel for a Personal Injury trial, here are a few things that, according to Florida Law, are withheld from the Jury:

1. Crash Reports – Did you know that in Florida, there is no such thing as an “accident report?” They are called Crash Reports, and the State of Florida officially renamed them crash reports in 1998. The rationale behind the renaming of the report follows that accidents may all be avoided if people would take appropriate care and caution, and only people who do not take the appropriate care and caution cause crashes. Florida law prevents the Jury from seeing the Crash Report. In order to encourage people to tell the truth to police officers at the scene of a crash, Florida Statute §316.066 essentially says a person can admit any wrongdoing that may have caused the crash but the information from the crash report cannot be used against them in a later trial. Section §316.066(7) of the Statue reads, “No such report or statement shall be used as evidence in any trial, civil or criminal.”

2. Citations – If someone was given a citation as result of a traffic crash, according to another Florida law, this information is also withheld from the Jury. Florida Statute §316.650(9) states “Such citations shall not be admissible evidence in any trial, except when used as evidence of falsification, forgery, uttering, fraud, or perjury, or when used as physical evidence resulting from a forensic examination of the citation.”

3. Insurance – Florida Statute §627.4136 entitled the Nonjoinder of Insurers says that juries are not to know about the amount of insurance available to protect the negligent defendant. The intent of the nonjoinder statute is to ensure that the availability of insurance has no influence on the jury’s determination of damages.

Before this statute, the law in Florida allowed people who were injured in a crash to bring a suit directly against the insurance company who insured the at-fault driver rather than filing suit directly against the at-fault driver. The law was changed and now prohibits any mention of insurance during the trial because it is believed that if the jury knew that there was insurance and that a person did not have to pay the damages personally, the damages given by the jury could be higher than if they thought there was no insurance to pay the loss. The other side to this is that without knowledge of insurance, the jury may be sympathetic to the at-fault driver with thoughts that their decision may impose severe financial harm on the defendant.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

The Shapiro Difference

  • Earning Your Trust

    Earning Your Trust. Not all attorneys are created equal. Marc Shapiro is reputable, experienced, trustworthy and is committed to both his clients and employees. We want you to be so satisfied with our law firm that you will tell your friends, family and colleagues that “Marc Shapiro is my attorney.”

  • Communication & Keeping you Informed

    We embrace technology and “simplexity.” Our legal assistants, paralegals, and attorneys will guide you through the process and make sure you are informed. We are available via text, phone and email and will promptly respond to your inquiry within one business day.

  • A Strong Office Culture

    We believe in growing people. The Shapiro team lives by three principles: Integrity, Communication, and Transparency. We mentor and nurture all levels of staff from interns to executives. A happy office means better service and more productivity for you.

  • Employing A+ Employees

    We look for employees with empathy and problem-solving ability. Many of our legal assistants, paralegals, & attorneys are bilingual and some even multilingual. Our staff is diverse and we speak Spanish, French, & Creole. We want to speak your language.

  • Grassroots Initiative & Community Engagement

    If you aren’t giving back then what are you doing? After the birth of Marc’s child, his life was transformed because of his son’s special needs. Marc routinely gives back to the Juvenile Diabetes Research Fund, volunteers with Autism Speaks and Autism awareness groups and STARability in Naples, Florida.

Retired Couple

Get a Complimentary
Strategy Session

Our team wants to help. Call or email us for a free consultation so we can evaluate your case and put you on the path to a successful recovery.

Contact Us

© 2020 - 2023 The Law Offices of Marc L. Shapiro, P.A. All rights reserved.
This law firm website and legal marketing are managed by MileMark Media.

Contact Form Tab
Schedule a CONFIDENTIAL Consultation
protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms